The Bush administration has no shortage of ideas. Unfortunately,
many of them are bad ones. Under the direction of Attorney General John
Ashcroft, whom NAACP Board Chair Julian Bond dubbed “J. Edgar Ashcroft”
because of his Hoover-like obsession with prying into the personal
lives of Americans, the administration had already launched a broad
attack on our civil liberties. But that wasn’t enough. So members
of the administration came up with the not-so-bright idea—actually, it
was dimwitted—of inaugurating a national program that encourages
Americans to spy on one another and report it to Uncle Sam. Washington
wouldn’t be Washington without an acronym that that fell out of bowl of
alphabet soup. So the would-be Secretary of Peeping Toms came up with
TIPS: Terrorism Information and Prevention System. Under the
pilot program that was to begin in August, certain citizens—mail
carriers, truckers, utility employees and others whose jobs provide
them a glimpse into people’s personal lives—would be urged to report
suspicious activity directly to the U.S. Justice Department. The
department would, in turn, share their database with local and state
authorities. This is such a bad idea that liberals and
conservatives united to oppose it. That they could come together
anytime is quite a feat. That they could unite in an election year is a
miracle. The Boston Globe’s liberal editorial page, under the
heading, “Ashcroft vs. Americans,” observed: “Ashcroft’s informant
corps is a vile idea not merely because it violates civil liberties in
a narrow legal sense or because it will sabotage genuine efforts to
prevent terrorism by overloading law enforcement officials with
irrelevant reports about Americans who have nothing to do with
terrorists. Operation TIPS should be stopped because it is utterly
anti-American. It would give Stalin and the KGB a delayed triumph in
the Cold War—in the name of the Bush administration’s war on terrorism.” Robert
A. Levy, writing for the conservative “National Review” observed, “If
the media accounts are to be believed, TIPS is crafted to transform us
into a nation of meddlers, busybodies, and snoops—each of us spying on
the rest.” He continues, “…We will soon have meter readers entering our
homes, supposedly to do what we expect them to do, then rummaging
around our private residences only to file a report with the Justice
Department about anything them deem questionable. “If police
officers wanted to do the same thing, they’d have to convince a judge
or magistrate that there was probable cause to issue a search warrant.
TIPS may not raise Fourth Amendment concerns, but it comes pretty
close.” House Majority Leader Dick Armey, a staunch supporter of
Bush, gave the administration a tip—forget about it. In his markup of
legislation creating a Homeland Security Department, the chairman of
the House Select Committee on Homeland Security explicitly prohibited
the Department of Justice from initiating TIPS. It also took another
step, requiring the creation of a privacy officer at the proposed
department. In the process of creating what Republicans say they
loathe, another level of bureaucracy, Armey opposed another bad idea
advanced by the Bush administration, one that would have created
national identification cards. Bush had favored either nationalizing
driver’s licenses or creating a national ID card. The 216-page bill,
sponsored by Armey, a conservative Republican from Bush’s home state,
also prohibits the creation of the national cards or uniform driver’s
licenses. “Authority to design and issue these cards shall remain with
the states,” Armey declared. Hold on, there’s more. The
latest dumb idea to come out of the White House is the prospect of
allowing the U.S. Army to assume a role in domestic law enforcement.
The “Posse Comitatus Act,” passed during the Reconstruction Era,
forbids the Army from participating in arrests, searches and seizure of
property within domestic borders. However, the Coast Guard and the
National Guard can be mobilized by governors in specific situations. “We
need to be talking about military assets in anticipation of a crisis
event,” Homeland security chief Tom Ridge said in an interview with
“Fox News Sunday.” Ridge said, “And clearly, if you’re talking about
using the military, then you should have a discussion about posse
comitatus.” However, Sen. Carl Levin, [D-Mich.] chairman of the
Senate Armed Services Committee, said the statue that has placed
restrictions on the use of the military in domestic matters has served
the country well. On CNN’s “Late Edition,” he explained, “It’s
kept the military out of law enforcement, out of arresting people
except in the most unusual emergency situations—like a riot or after
some kind of a disaster, where they have to protect against looting.” At
the rate we’re going, Bush’s next proposal might be that we declare the
Constitution unconstitutional. Hey, don’t laugh. No one thought he’d
come up with this many bad ideas in such a short period in office. When
it comes to bad ideas, there seems to be no end.
Next Column:
Private Schools and Public Lies
Back To Columns |