In the wake of having their heads handed to them on a platter, the
Democrats since Election Day have made two steps in the opposite
direction. They got off on a good foot by selecting a new, diverse
leadership team in the House. But they acted like the usual wimps by
advancing two Right-wing judicial nominations out of committee in the
lame duck session of Congress. Let’s get the bad news out of the
way first. Even before Republicans take control of the Senate in
January, the Democrats on the Judiciary Committee are already rolling
over and playing dead. Actually, they don’t have to play—they are dead.
Committee Chairman Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) had held off
considering the elevation of U.S. District Judge Dennis Shedd to the
4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and the appointment of Utah law
professor Michael McConnell to the 10th Court of Appeals. Leahy
said the two nominations were too contentious to bring before the
committee prior to the Nov. 5 election. After the election, Leahy is
being anything but contentious. Even though Democrats hold a 10-9 edge
in committee, he guided the nominations through committee and reported
them to the floor for a Senate vote. Shedd, a former aide to
retiring Sen. Strom Thurmond (R-S.C.), dismissed a lawsuit aimed at
removing the Confederate flag from the statehouse dome, asserting that
South Carolinians “don’t care if the flags flies or not.” He has ruled
consistently against civil rights plaintiffs. McConnell, who has
the backing of ultra-conservative Orrin Hatch (R-Utah), is so hostile
to civil rights that he opposes the concept of one person, one vote. He
even objected to the Supreme Court decision denying tax exempt status
to Bob Jones University for racially discriminatory policies. After
the Senate vote, Wade Henderson, executive director of the Leadership
Conference on Civil Rights, a federation of 180 civil and human rights
groups, said: “Regardless of the outcome of the election, there is no
presidential mandate for a Right-wing judiciary.” Not only did
the Judiciary Committee send the nominations out of committee, they
also sent a message to progressives, Henderson said. “Senators
who voted to confirm Dennis Shedd and Michael McConnell send a clear
signal to women, racial minorities, workers and consumers across
America that their voices will not be heard,” he said. “The message is
that nominees who are hostile to civil rights, women’s rights and
Congress’ authority to protect those rights, will get lifetime
appointments where they can limit or even roll back progress on civil
rights and civil liberties.” That’s the bad news. The good
news is that Democrats elected a leadership team that reflects more
than just White males. They elected Nancy Pelosi, an unapologetic
liberal from San Francisco, as minority leader in the House. She voted
against the Bush tax cuts and opposed authorizing the use of force
against Iraq. Also elected were Steny H. Hoyer of Maryland as
whip, Robert Menendez, a Hispanic from New Jersey as caucus chairman
and James E. Clyburn, a former chairman of the Congressional Black
Caucus from South Carolina, as vice chairman of the Democratic caucus.
Pelosi named John M. Spratt Jr., a fiscal conservative from South
Carolina, as assistant to the leader. Pelosi, an experienced
lawmaker, made it clear that her priority will be challenging
Republicans on the economy. That’s George W. Bush’s Achilles’ heel. If they are ever to regain power, Democrats must get back to their bread-and-butter issues. The
combination of corporate scandals, including a major one in Bush’s home
state, and massive job losses across the country provides issues
perfectly tailored for the Democratic Party. I am not a political
consultant, and I don’t play one on TV. But if I were, I would have the
Democratic candidate raise a few questions at each gathering. Anytime a
room full of voters were gathered, I’d ask those who had been
“downsized” to raise their hand? With their hands still in the air, I’d
ask: How many of you have relatives who have recently lost their jobs?
With those hands also in the air, I’d ask: How many of you have friends
or neighbors who’ve lost their jobs? At the end of that exercise,
the point would have been made, and I’d have the Democrats depict
themselves as the friend of workers and Republicans as the surrogates
of big business. I’d ask the public to choose between the two. But
Democrats must stand for something. And stand tall. They can’t stay in
hot pursuit of the elusive Bubba vote while ignoring the voters who
brought them this far. Bill Clinton demonstrated that even though
he received a minority of the White vote in 1996, Democrats can offset
that with an energized turnout of African-Americans and other people of
color, women and labor. And the farther Democrats move away from their
base, the farther they move from ever recapturing any branch of
government.
Next Column:
Democrats Should 'Lease' some Political Courage
Back To Columns |