To Samuel P. Golden, ombudsman in the Office of the Comptroller of
the Currency, nothing more graphically illustrates the shortcomings of
the banking industry’s efforts to reach people of color than the case
of Joe Guillen, a professional baseball player. “Last month, the
Washington Post reported a purse-snatching of the sort that is
regrettably too common and routine on the streets of our big cities,”
Golden said in a speech at the Urban Financial Services Coalition’s
annual convention in Dallas. “However, this incident warranted press
coverage because Jose Guillen, a player on the Washington Nationals
baseball team, was impacted by the robbery. Per the newspaper, Mr.
Guillen’s 24-year-old girlfriend had just finished cashing his paycheck
and wiring some of the proceeds back home. Almost before she knew what
happened, a thief made off with the cash.” Warming to his
subject, Golden said, “There are two remarkable aspects to this story.
First, Mr. Guillen reportedly earns $4 million a year playing baseball;
his weekly salary check was $12,000. Secondly, when the purse was
snatched, his girlfriend was emerging not from a bank, but from a local
check-cashing establishment. “So I ask you: if a person well paid
even by major league baseball standards – someone with the best agents
and technical advisers at his disposal – chooses to rely on nonetheless
on a local check cashier, despite their notorious fees and security
risks, what does it say about the barriers that still exist between the
banking system and millions of Americans, especially those whose first
language is not English? In other words, if financially-prominent
individuals haven’t been persuaded to use direct deposit and regular
banking services, is it any wonder that millions of others of lesser
means and sophistication continue to rely on storefront money service
businesses?” Hispanics are expected to double their presence in
the U.S. over the next 50 years, making up a quarter of the nation’s
population. The Census Bureau projects that shortly after 2050,
Hispanics, Blacks and Asians will constitute more that 50 percent of
the population, making Whites a minority in the U.S. population for the
first time. “The question is, how well prepared is the banking
industry for this sweeping change in our national demographics?” Golden
asked. “Judging by the Washington Post story, the answer would seem to
be, not as well as it needs to be.” Golden pointed out that
people of color are overrepresented among the 10 percent of households
that are “unbanked,” meaning they do not have regular accounts at
federally-insured institutions. “It is precisely those
households that rely inordinately on cash checking establishments,
rent-to-own outlets, pawnshops, and payday lenders to conduct their
basic financial business. In so doing they pay a heavy price – not only
in fees and potential loss due to theft, as Mr. Guillen discovered, but
also in the credit histories that these households are not building
through integration in the mainstream financial system.” In
addition to underserving the so-called fringe banking customers, Golden
said financial institutions may be hurting themselves with their
“incredible shrinking grace period.” He continued, “And, always, the
fees: late fees, overlimit fees, and balance transfer fees that seem to
go only in one direction. That would be the same direction people’s
blood pressure goes when they see that the outstanding balance on which
they have been paying 15 percent APR is now going to cost them 32
percent because they were a few days late in paying an electric bill.” Golden,
an African-American, told members of the Urban Financial Services
Coalition that because they are Black, they have a special obligation
to argue against practices that could, in the end, harm both the
industry and people of color. “While the bank’s reputation with
its customers is a priceless asset, it is also a perishable one,” he
reminded them. “I would argue that real leadership consists not only in
recognizing that fact, but, even more, becoming an advocate for it.” The
Urban Financial Services Coalition, formerly known as the National
Association of Urban Bankers, for years had a good age mix among its
members. Now, largely because of numerous mergers and acquisitions that
led to many older bankers retiring early or accepting buyouts, the
association’s members tend to be younger, many of them in their 30s.
And the younger trend may continue if banks continue to alienate their
customers. “We have long contended that some consumer banking
practices walk a dangerous tightrope between what’s impermissible and
what is merely shortsighted, injudicious, and inadvisable,” Golden
said. “This reminds me of the saying I heard from my Dad – ‘pigs get
fat, but hogs get slaughtered.’ Your retail customers should never be
viewed as a feeding ground. While overreaching for short-term gain is
understandable, excessive greed for profits, at any cost, is never
wise.”
Next Column:
The Birth of Black Aviation
Back To Columns |