Writing in the nation’s first Black-owned newspaper, Freedom’s
Journal, Samuel Cornish and John B. Russwurm, stated: “We wish to plead
our own cause. Too long have others spoken for us.” That was in 1827.
This week, 177 years later, the National Newspaper Publishers
Association (NNPA), is celebrating its annual Black Press Week. A
week ago, the need for an alternative to the White-owned media was
underscored in a voluminous study of the industry by the Project for
Excellence in Journalism, an institute affiliated with Columbia
University Graduate School of Journalism (The report can be downloaded
from the Web site, stateofthemedia.org). It offers some
disturbing reminders about the corporate dominance of the news media.
In the newspaper industry, 22 companies now represent 70 percent of the
daily circulation and 73 percent on Sunday. Four companies – Time
Warner, Hearst, Advance and Primedia – receive about 50 percent of all
magazine ad revenue. In local television, the 10 largest companies own
30 percent of all TV stations, reaching 85 percent of all U.S.
households. In radio, the top 20 companies operate more than 20
percent of all radio stations in the country. One of them, Clear
Channel, has unmatched clout because it owns more than 1,000 stations,
including 191 of the 289 stations in Arbitron-rated markets. All three
major networks are owned by large corporations for whom television
represents only a small share of their annual revenues. And on the
Internet, more than half of the top 20 sites are owned by one of the 20
largest media companies. Does bigger mean better, as the conglomerates like to argue? Not
if you’re judging by content. Take those around-the-clock television
cable networks. The study found that 68 percent of what you hear and
see on cable TV is repetitious. And local television news has its own
problems. The notion that “if it bleeds, it leads,” is still the order
of the day. Half of the lead stories on local television stations are
about a crime or a minor fire or accident. Viewers and readers also have a growing distrust of the media. Between
1986 and 2002, the study found, “the percentage of Americans who rated
their daily newspaper as highly believable fell from 80 to 59 percent.
ABC News fell from 83 to 65 percent, CBS from 84 to 64 percent, and NBC
from 82 to 66 percent. Local news stations fell from 81 to 65 percent.”
The proliferation of news outlets has had mixed results. “Network
news, news magazines, and newspaper front pages carry a wider range of
topics,” the report notes. “But a good deal of the new diversity is in
lighter fare – lifestyle, entertainment, consumer news – rather than
news about diverse communities or populations.” Nowhere is that
more evident than in the newsmagazines. Drawing on 20 years of data
from Hall’s Reports, a Stamford, Conn.-based research firm, the study
observes: “Pages devoted to national affairs, for instance, dropped by
25 percent from 1980 to the first half of 2003…There is less news on
high culture such as museum reviews (13 percent in 1980 versus 10
percent in 2003), and, perhaps surprisingly, a smaller percent of pages
devoted to business (11 percent versus 9 percent). “… What
subjects now take up the pages? The space devoted to entertainment and
celebrity stories has roughly doubled since 1980 (and now accounts for
7 percent of the pages). Lifestyle coverage has grown from a scant 1
percent in 1980 to 4 percent in 2003. Health news, which often
translates to news you can use rather than medical science, has more
than quadrupled (from 2 percent in 1980 to 9 percent in 2003.)” For reliable and substantive news about African-Americans, Blacks must turn to the Black Press. For
example, this week’s NNPA papers are carrying an exclusive interview
with John Kerry, the Democratic Party’s presidential
nominee-in-waiting. Despite the horde of reporters who travel with the
Massachusetts senator and the dozens of televised Democratic debates,
his interview with NNPA News Service Washington Correspondent Hazel
Trice Edney provides answers to questions that the traveling press did
not think or care to ask, such as the first time he took a stand on
civil rights. In another NNPA News Service story, Al Sharpton
accuses Black Democrats who backed the unsuccessful presidential bid of
Howard Dean of ending up empty-handed, a position they wouldn’t be in
had they unified around his campaign. These aren’t the stories
that routinely interest the White-owned media. And that’s why the Black
Press continues to play such a vital role by covering issues that are
important to us and by pleading our own cause.
Next Column:
The 'Big Lie’ About Kerry’s Record
Back To Columns |