In an effort to neutralize Black leaders or have Hispanics supplant
African-Americans as the nation’s primary minority group, some people
gleefully note that Hispanics now outnumber African-Americans. However,
as a recent CBS/New York Times poll shows, the Latino community is
deeply fractured and does not share a common past that unites
African-Americans on social policy issues.To compare Blacks and
Hispanics is to engage in a flawed analysis. First, while
African-Americans have been and remain America’s largest racial group,
Hispanics are part of an ethnic group, not a racial one. Therefore, a
Hispanic can be Black, White, Asian or of any race. Furthermore, 1.7
million Blacks identified themselves as Hispanic. If they were
officially counted as Black, African-Americans would still outnumber
Hispanics, though not for long. According to a recent Census
report, the first since the 2000 tally, the U.S. population grew by 2.5
percent to 288.4 million from the time of the April 2000 census to July
2001. Non-Hispanic Blacks grew up 3.1 percent, to 36.6 million, over
that period. Meanwhile, the Latino population grew at 9.8 percent, a
rate faster than all other groups, to 38.8 million. As the
Republican Party targets more Latinos, the New York Times/CBS poll
shows that there are political landmines for both major parties. The
good news for George Bush is that while Latinos favor the Democratic
Party over the GOP by a large margin, they approve of Bush’s job
performance 52 percent to 38 percent. They also support key Republican
issues, such as tax cuts and school vouchers. But Democrats can
take heart because Hispanics are twice as likely to identify themselves
as Democrats and by an overwhelming margin — 49 percent to 21 percent
—feel the Democratic Party is more likely to care of their needs than
Republicans. As the Bush administration touts a smaller federal
government, 75 percent of Hispanics said they want a larger federal
government that provides expanded services. While
African-Americans vote Democratic 80 percent to 90 percent of the time,
Hispanics are far less homogeneous politically and culturally. And they
are far more likely to identify with their country of origin rather
than as Hispanic or Latino. According to the Census Bureau, two thirds
of all Latinos here (66.9 percent) list their country of origin as
Mexico; 14.3 percent are from Central and South America; 8.6 percent
are Puerto Rican; Cubans represent 3.7 percent and 6.5 percent come
from other countries. Politically, Mexicans in California and Puerto
Ricans in New York tend to be liberal on social issues, while Cubans in
Florida tend to be staunch conservatives. Thus, there is no one size
that fits all. On another level, Hispanics, regardless of their
leanings, are more conservative than the overall population on such
hot-button issues as abortion and same-sex marriages. And Bush is
trying to solidify his conservative base and appeal to Hispanic voters
by supporting legislation that only recognizes marriages between males
and females. The sleeper in next year’s election might be how
Democrats handle or mishandle issues important to the religious
community. And I am not talking about the Pat Robertses or the Jerry
Falwells of the world. I am talking about the everyday people who sit
next to you in church on Sunday. I am surprised by the number
of politically liberal African-American Christians who have told me
that they either voted for George Bush the last time out or did not
cast a ballot because of Al Gore’s position on such issues as abortion.
These are people who are strong proponents of affirmative action and
civil rights but don’t like the positions Democrats take on “moral”
issues. “I don’t have anything against gays, I don’t think people
should discriminate against them, but I don’t believe we should
sanction gay marriages,” a loyal Democrat told me recently. And
although the U.S. Supreme Court recently struck down a Texas sodomy law
that prohibited homosexual acts between consenting adults, public
opinion remains almost evenly divided on the issue. Strategically,
the Democratic Party can’t afford to alienate Blacks, its most loyal
base. While Hispanics are being labeled America’s “largest minority”
group, that does not translate into the largest clout at the polls. It
is estimated that one of seven Hispanics is in this country illegally,
many others can’t vote because they are not naturalized citizens and
still others are simply too young to vote. According to the Pew
Hispanic Center at the University of Southern California, there are
twice as many Black voters as Hispanic voters. Hoopla aside,
African-Americans still have the clout at the ballot box. Now, all we
have to do is exercise it.
Next Column:
Jessica Lynch: Weapon of Mass Distortion
Back To Columns |