Undeterred by the Senate Judiciary Committee’s rejection of two of
his Far Right nominees to serve as federal appeals court judges, a
determined George W. Bush is now trying to appoint a law professor who
opposed a landmark U.S. Supreme Court ruling that withheld the
tax-exempt status of Bob Jones University because it discriminated
against African-Americans. On Wednesday, the Senate Judiciary
Committee began hearings on the nomination of Michael McConnell to
become a member of the United States Court of Appeals for the 10th
Circuit in Denver. McConnell is a law professor at the University of
Utah. In a 1983 ruling, by a vote of 8-1, the Supreme Court held
that the Internal Revenue Service was correct in denying tax-exempt
status to Bob Jones University because its policies violated the 1964
Civil Rights Act. Initially, the private conservative, evangelical
university in Greenville, S.C., refused to admit any African-Americans.
But it later revised its policies to admit Blacks as long as they did
not date or marry across racial lines, a prohibition that was
eventually dropped. At the time of the suit, Bob Jones University regulations stated: *There is to be no interracial dating *
Students who are members of or affiliated with any group or
organization which holds as one of its goals or advocates interracial
marriage will be expelled. * Students who date outside of their own race will be expelled. * Students who espouse, promote, or encourage others to violate the University’s dating rules and regulations will be expelled. When
the Internal Revenue Service notified the university that it would no
longer be considered a tax-exempt charitable organization under section
501 (c )(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954 as long as its
discriminatory policies were in place, the university went to court. A
district court in South Carolina sided with the school. However, an
appeals court and, later, the U.S. Supreme Court, ruled in favor of the
IRS. Only William Rehnquist, who is now the chief justice of the
Supreme Court, dissented in the case. The court’s majority
concluded that all three levels of the federal government had made it
clear that there is a national policy against racial discrimination in
education and that the federal government has a direct interest in
eradicating discrimination, even in religious schools. McConnell,
the president’s choice to sit on the nation’s second-highest court,
cited the ruling an egregious example of the Supreme Court’s failure to
“intervene to protect religious freedom from the heavy hand of
government.” The Senate Judiciary Committee is evaluating
McConnell’s fitness for the job. He signed a petition calling on
Congress to pass a Constitutional amendment outlawing all abortions,
wrote a brief for the Supreme Court arguing that the Boy Scouts had a
constitutional right to discriminate against gays and wants to further
destroy the wall in the constitution separating state and church. Civil
rights activists are citing the nomination of McConnell as yet another
example of Bush’s determination to appoint federal judges whose views
are far right of American mainstream opinion. “On too many
constitutional rights and civil liberties issues, Michael McConnell may
be the most dangerous Bush administration judicial nominee to come
before the Judiciary Committee,” says Ralph G. Neas, president of
People For the American Way. “His longstanding views on some
fundamental constitutional and legal principles are to the right even
of the most conservative justices now on the Supreme Court.” Barry
Lynn, of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, says
McConnell is so extreme that he makes failed Supreme Court nominee
Robert Bork “look moderate.” After the Senate Judiciary
Committee had rejected the nominations of District Judge Charles W.
Pickering Sr. of Mississippi and, more recently, Texas Supreme Court
Justice Priscilla Owen, who was even to the right of Bush’s appointees
on the state court, one would expect that Bush would nominate judges
with more mainstream views. But his nomination of Pickering, Owen and
McConnell to serve as appeals court judges underscores his
determination to pack the courts with rabid Right-wingers. Bush
was made acutely aware of Bob Jones’ history in March 2000 when he was
campaigning for president. Bush decided to give a speech at the
university during the South Carolina Republican primary even though the
school had not yet lifted its ban on interracial dating. Bush’s
decision to speak at Bob Jones reminds me of Ronald Reagan’s decision
to kick off his 1980 presidential campaign with a speech at the Neshoba
County Fair in Philadelphia, Miss., the site where the bodies of three
civil rights workers—James Chaney, Michael Schwerner and Andrew
Goodman—were recovered in 1964. They were part of Freedom Summer, a
project to help African-Americans vote in Mississippi. Reagan’s
decision to go to Philadelphia, Miss., and George W. Bush’s decision to
speak at Bob Jones University spoke volumes. And so does Bush’s
decision to nominate a lawyer who feels that the university’s
discriminatory polices should be subsidized by taxpayers’ dollars.
Previous Column:
Bureaucratic Bunglers Hamper Anti-Terrorism Plans
Back To Columns |