By the time you read this, I expect the Supreme Court would have
issued an opinion placing limitations on the use of race in assigning
students to public schools. If that happens, it will continue a trend
began in the 1990s that eroded significant desegregation gains,
especially in the South. This won't be the first Supreme Court
decision that undermines the 1954 Brown v. Board of Education rulings
outlawing so-called separate but equal schools. The Brown decision
proved that the legal system could effectively change the makeup of
targeted school districts. A report issued last year titled, “Racial
Transformation and the Changing Nature of Segregation,” by Gary Orfield
and Chungmei Lee of The Civil Rights Project at Harvard University,
provides an array of data that illustrates this point. For
example, it noted that during the peak of the Civil Rights Era, between
1964 and 1970, Blacks in majority White schools in the South jumped
from 2 percent to 33 percent, making it the least segregated region in
the country. That progress was paved by President Lyndon
Johnson, an outspoken advocate of desegregation, a sympathetic Supreme
Court led by Chief Justice Earl Warren and passage of the 1964 Civil
Rights Act. After years of progress – and a less compassionate public climate -- public schools are being resegregated. The
report notes, “The resegregation of blacks is greatest in the Southern
and Border states and appears to be clearly related to the Supreme
Court decisions in the 1990s permitting return to segregated
neighborhood schools.” In Board of Education of Oklahoma v.
Dowell (1991), the Supreme Court allowed school districts to return to
segregated neighborhood schools. In Freeman v. Pitts (1992), the
Supreme Court allowed districts to terminate desegregation programs
even though integration had not been achieved. And in Missouri v.
Jenkins (1995), the Court emphasized the priority of local control of
schools over desegregation. Even with the adverse rulings, the
report notes, schools in the South and Border states among the most
desegregated in the nation. On the other hand, schools in New York,
Illinois, California and Michigan were the most segregated, with the
average Black students attending schools that had less than a quarter
of students who were White. Unlike the 1960s, school
desegregation is no longer a Black/White paradigm. Latinos are the
fastest-growing group in the U.S. and they, too, are pushed to the back
of the school bus. “Latino segregation is higher than black
segregation on some measures in the South and West,” the Harvard study
said. “In the West, where Latinos are concentrated, 81 percent of
Latinos are in schools with nonwhite majorities, followed by 78 percent
in the Northeast and South.” Schools are a preview of what is to come. “Since
the 2000 Census a great deal has been written about the demographic
transformation underway in many American communities as the U.S. moves
toward the day when citizens of European background will no longer be
the majority, but the changes are much more rapid and dramatic in the
school age population,” the report stated. Although the White
population in the U.S. is not projected to dwindle to 50 percent until
2050, that ratio has already been reached in many schools systems. “The
South, the nation’s most populous region in 2003, had 50 percent white
students while the West had 47 percent,” the report said. “While the
South has always been home to the majority of U.S. blacks and has by
far the highest proportion of black students at 27 percent, it is also
a region where Latino enrollment is rising rapidly so that in the
2003-04 school year, one in five of its students are Latino. Even in
the South, where the traditional black-white models of U.S. race
relations are most deeply rooted, the framework is clearly breaking
down.” But no one should be confused about why African-Americans sought to enroll in desegregated schools. “There
is no evidence that the long struggle of civil rights groups to end
segregation was only motivated by a desire to have minority children
sit next to white children,” the Harvard report stated. “There was a
strong belief that predominantly white schools offered better
opportunities on many levels…” It is disturbing that at a time
when the U.S. is undergoing a major demographic transition, few
high-ranking officials have publicly voiced the need for all groups to
prepare to live in a fast-approaching multi-cultural society in which
Whites will be in a minority and no group will constitute a majority. “In
a survey conducted in 2003, more than half (57%) of adults surveyed
believed that racially integrated schools are better for kids, and only
seven percent believed in the opposite,” the Harvard report observed.
”The fact that desegregation is not being discussed by political and
most educational leaders does not mean that it is not highly important
or that it failed or that there were no viable alternatives, only that
it is controversial.”
Next Column:
Black Journalists Fill ‘Missing Pages’
Back To Columns |