The future alignment of the Supreme Court - not Joe the Plumber or
William Ayers - is one the most important issues in Tuesday's
presidential election. The justices most likely to retire next
are two liberals: John Paul Stevens, 88, and Ruth Bader Ginsburg, 75.
That means that if McCain follows through on a pledge to appoint
conservative judges, a Supreme Court divided 5-4 on many hot-button
issues will swing dramatically to the right. On the other hand, an
Obama victory, even if accompanied by a Democratic landslide in the
Senate, would mean that the court retains its current balance during
Obama's first term. Obama and McCain offer a stark contrast in the kind of justices they would appoint to the Supreme Court. In
a speech in May at Wake Forest University, McCain said: "I will look
for accomplished men and women with a proven record of excellence in
the law and a proven commitment to judicial restraint. I will look for
people in the cast of John Roberts, Samuel Alito, and my friend the
late William Rehnquist - jurists of the highest caliber, who know their
own minds, and know the law, and know the difference." Reacting
to the Supreme Court's decision last year forbidding the consideration
of race in determining which schools students could attend in Seattle
and Louisville, Obama issued a statement saying, "Chief Justice
Roberts' opinion reflects a disturbing view of the Constitution that
equates voluntary integration with Jim Crow segregation - a view that
is both legally and morally wrong. The policies that led to racially
diverse schools in Seattle and Louisville are a far cry from the
policies and racial subordination that led to blacks-only and
whites-only schools in the pre-Brown [v. Board of Education] era. To
equate the two is to turn a blind eye to our nation's history." He
added, "As president, I will appoint Supreme Court justices who
understand the constitutional importance of Brown. Those justices will
ultimately vindicate Brown's promise, as Justice [Stephen] Breyer and
today's dissenters put it, of 'one law, one nation, one people, not
simply as a matter of legal principle, but in terms of how we actually
live.' " The Supreme Court is divided into two factions. In the
conservative camp are Roberts, Alito, Antonin Scalia and Clarence
Thomas. On the liberal side are Stevens, Ginsburg, Breyer and David
Souter. Depending on the issue, Anthony Kennedy votes with either side. Of
the nine sitting justices, seven - all except Ginsburg and Breyer -
were appointed by Republican presidents. Eleven of the last 13 Supreme
Court appointments have been made by Republicans. If McCain wins
the election and appoints yet another conservative to the bench - which
will be more difficult if Democrats extend their advantage in the
Senate, which confirms or rejects judicial nominees - it will have dire
consequences for affirmative action and other policies. In 2003,
a 5-4 majority of the Supreme Court approved the use of race as a
factor in the admission of qualified students to the University of
Michigan Law School. In that case, Grutter v. Bollinger, Justice Sandra
Day O'Connor supplied the key fifth vote. O'Connor, who was the
court's swing vote, retired and was replaced in 2006 by Samuel Alito, a
solid conservative. The appointment of one more justice in the mode of
Roberts and Alito will give conservatives a five-vote majority without
Kennedy, the court's current swing vote. Possibly more important
than appointments to the Supreme Court are those to the lower courts.
According to National Journal, only 0.1 percent of the 60,000 cases
appealed each year are taken up by the Supreme Court.
Republican-appointed judges hold 54 percent of the 674 full-time U.S.
District Court judgeships, and 56 percent of the 179 seats on 13 Courts
of Appeals circuits. A McCain presidency would widen that Republican advantage, and an Obama administration would narrow it. Meanwhile,
a reshaped Supreme Court, in addition to possibly eliminating or
severely restricting affirmative action, could leave its imprint on
other major issues, such as abortion rights, gun control, government
funding of religious schools, the death penalty, civil liberties, and
consumer rights. Tuesday's election is not only a choice between
Obama and McCain; it's also a referendum on the future of the Supreme
Court and the direction it will take the nation.
Next Column:
Vote to Make Your Ancestors Proud
Back To Columns |