It is a scene that is becoming increasingly familiar. An
African-American youth, usually a male 13 or 14 years old, sits in a
courtroom with a blank expression on his face, unable to fully grasp
the complexity of a criminal justice system that is about to treat him
as an adult. The most recent case involves Lionel Tate, 14, who
was sentenced to life in prison without parole in Florida for the death
of a 6-year-old playmate. Jurors found Tate guilty of first-degree
murder after dismissing his lawyers’ claim that the boy, who was
12-years-old at the time, was merely imitating the antics of
professional wrestlers he had watched on television. You wouldn’t
know it by the haunting images of handcuffed youth in the media, but
juvenile crime is on the decline, reaching its lowest level in a
generation. In December, the U.S. Justice Department’s Office of
Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention reported that juvenile
crime has been falling for the past six years. The rate of homicide
arrests in the 10-17 age group has dropped 68 percent, reaching its
lowest level since 1966. Juvenile crime rates for the most serious
violent crimes - murder, rape, robbery and aggravated assault - is down
by 36 percent, according to FBI statistics. The Justice Department reported: - The juvenile arrest rate for weapon crimes dropped 39 percent from 1993, the lowest level since 1988; - Rape by juveniles was down 31 percent from 1991 to 1999, the lowest level since 1980; - Robbery by teens was down 53 percent from 1994, the lowest level since 1989; - Burglary was down 60 percent from 1980; - Larceny-theft fell 23 percent from 1997; - Auto theft among teens was down 52 percent from 1990. In
addition to the overall drop in juvenile crime, James Alan Fox, a noted
criminal justice professor at Northeastern University in Boston, has
produced additional research that shows a huge drop in the number of
Black teens arrested for murder. According to Fox, murders committed by
African-American youth age 14-17 fell from 244.1 per 100,000 youth in
1993 to 67.3 in 1999. Two areas in which juvenile arrests had
climbed during the 1990s - drug abuse violations and loitering - have
also begun to drop. No one factor accounts for the decline in
teen crime. Experts have cited reasons ranging from a booming economy
to tougher laws for juvenile offenders and a surge in after-school
programs, the time period in which most teens commit crimes. What
makes the decreases even more impressive is that they came during a
period that the youth population was experiencing a slight increase. These
numbers do not mean that juvenile crime is no longer a serious problem.
To the contrary, African-American males 14 to 17 years old are six
times as likely to commit a violent crime as their White counterparts.
Black males in this age group are also six times as likely to be a
homicide victim. More stunning than the drop in juvenile crime is
the dramatic difference in how White and African-American teens are
treated by the juvenile justice system. According to a report
issued by the Washington, D.C.-based Youth Law Center, titled “And
Justice for Some,” Black youth who had no previous involvement with the
juvenile justice system were six times more likely to be sentenced by
juvenile court to the equivalent of juvenile prison. Among youth
charged with violent crimes for the first time, Black teens were nine
times more likely than Whites to be sentenced to prison. Black
teens arrested on drug charges were 48 times more likely than Whites to
be sentenced to juvenile prison. Even when White and Black youth were
charged with the same violent crime, Whites served an average of 193
days after trial, Blacks served 254 days and Hispanics 305 days. “The
people in the system are looking at African-American kids and are
thinking, ‘Drugs,’ and are thinking, ‘We’ve got to punish them,’” Mark
Soler, president of the Youth Law Center in Washington, D.C. said in an
interview with National Public Radio. “And when they look at White kids
charged with the same offenses, they are not making the same kind of
assumptions about who these kids are. And that shows all the way from
arrest all the way through sentencing.” Lionel Tate, the teen in
Florida, was sentenced to life under Florida’s mandatory sentencing
provisions. He is the youngest person serving a life sentence in the
United States. Florida Gov. Jeb Bush has pledged to review Tate’s case
when it is formally presented to him. As long as states continue
to pass get-tough laws aimed at juveniles, as long as prosecutors are
granted the power to usurp a judge’s prerogative and decide for
themselves whether teens should be tried in adult courts, as long as
politicians shamelessly exploit the juvenile crime issue and as long as
the public is ignorant about whether juvenile crime is up and down, we
can expect to see more kids ending up like Lionel Tate, another Black
face staring at us blankly.
Next Column:
Distorting the Affirmative Action Debate
Back To Columns |