The news media loves anniversaries. If it’s the first or a round
figure, like 10, that’s even better. That’s why we’ve seen so many
stories on the 10th anniversary of the Los Angeles rebellion and the
first anniversary of a similar uproar in Cincinnati. But we must move
beyond artificial time markers. In its reflective mode, the media
has done a job of comparing the past with the present. But it has not
spent enough attention exposing the root cause of the uprisings. In Los
Angeles, the community reaction followed the acquittal of four White
police officers for beating Rodney King. Although the savage beating
was captured on videotape, we were asked not to believe our eyes. In
Cincinnati, it was a different city but a similar script. Again, the
outbreak was prompted by a police action, in this case, the shooting of
an unarmed Black man. The U.S. Justice Department recently announced
that it had reached an agreement with the City of Cincinnati on how to
improve the police department. Long before the incidents in Los
Angeles and Cincinnati, the National Advisory Commission on Civil
Rights, known as the Kerner Commission, issued its findings on the
causes of widespread urban unrest during the summer of 1967, unrest
that spread to more than 150 cities. In warned that, “Our Nation is
moving toward two societies, one black, one, white–separate and
unequal.” As we observe anniversaries–of the 1965 rebellion in
Watts, the 1982 outbreak in Los Angeles and the 2001 flames in
Cincinnati -- we should remember another finding of the Kerner
Commission: Most urban rebellions are ignited by police misbehavior. The
key question is not being addressed in the rush to commemorate, if not
celebrate, the passage of time. What happens to cops who misbehave? In
1992–10 years ago–Gannett News Service decided to seek an answer to
that question. Its findings were as startling as the Kerner Commission
noting that we were moving toward two separate societies. The
news service examined 100 civil lawsuits that had been filed against
police officers in 22 states. In each instance, awards of $100,000 or
more were made to victims between 1986 and 1991; the total was nearly
$92 million. And what happened to the cops that had cost taxpayers
money? Of the 185 officers involved in the cases, no disciplinary
action was taken against 160, eight were disciplined and 17 were
promoted. In other words, a cop accused of police brutality was two
times more likely to get promoted than disciplined. Five or 10
years from now—or whenever the next anniversary is observed—someone
should go back to see what happened to the cops involved in Cincinnati
and other communities. We know that subsequent trials sent some Los
Angeles cops to jail while acquitting others. The issue is one of
providing consistent police accountability. Most police officers
have not been accused of police brutality and the complaints filed tend
to name the same officers, which is a clear indication that something
is amiss. Even fair-minded cops are being ill-served by some of their
fellow officers. “Police departments like to claim that each
high-profile abuse is an aberration, committed by a ‘rogue officer,’”
says Kenneth Roth, executive director of Human Rights Watch. “But these
human rights violations persists because the accountability systems are
so defective.” To make the systems effective, Human Rights Watch
recommends making federal aid to police departments contingent upon
regular reporting of incidents of excessive force, departments
establishing a zero tolerance for abuse by its officers, having
effective civilian review agencies and hiring special prosecutors to go
after abusive police officers. The police and most
African-Americans want the same thing – to rid our communities of
crime. However, this effort can’t be successful if the people who are
supposed to be protected by police are being mistreated by the very
people who are supposed to be protecting them. As they Gannett News
Service investigation found, “Taxpayers are penalized more for
brutality than the officers responsible for the beatings.”
Next Column:
Being Good is not Good Enough
Back To Columns |