Many analysts are remarking on what a shame it is that con man
Jayson Blair has caused the downfall of a Gerald M. Boyd, managing
editor of “The New York Times,” the newspaper’s highest ranking
African-American. They have it all wrong. Sure, Blair provided the
opening for Boyd’s resignation, but the true culprit was Executive
Editor Howell Raines, whose imperial management style had alienated
most of the staff. News accounts about the tandem have focused on
Raines and have mentioned Boyd only in passing. In fact, Boyd differed
with many of Raines approaches, including how he handled the Blair
blowup, and was quite vocal in editorial meetings. When speaking with
others, however, he has been the loyal soldier, making sure whatever
criticisms he had remained within the “Times” family. Those who
seek to depict Gerald Boyd as an appendage of Howell Raines don’t know
Gerald Boyd. I do. And I’ve known him throughout his 30-year career,
beginning after his graduation from the University of Missouri in
Columbia when he joined the staff of the “St. Louis Post-Dispatch,”
where I was already a reporter. I also knew his wife at the time,
Sheila Rule, now a “Times” recruiter. We lived across the street from
one another, played a card game known as “dirty hearts,” and have
remained friends over the years. I had breakfast with Gerald a
couple of weeks ago in New York. Although I am editing an anthology on
the Jayson Blair fiasco, we were not meeting in a professional
capacity. We were meeting as friends; I had called to let Gerald know
that I would be in the city and that I wanted to see him. Without
violating any confidences, suffice it to say Gerald was more concerned
about the survival of “The New York Times” as an institution than his
survival as managing editor. I admit that I didn’t think the scandal
would lead to the resignations of the paper’s top two editors, but at
the time, Gerald wasn’t so sure. “You’re going to come out of
this alright,” I told him. “You’re going to be fine.” Gerald replied,
“I’m not worried about me. I have a wife and son who love me, and
that’s what’s most important.” It’s been hard for me to watch
from the sidelines as Gerald’s hard-earned reputation has been sullied.
And it must have been doubly so for Gerald and his wife, Robin Stone,
who once worked at the “Times.” What has been particularly
galling has been the insinuation that because Gerald is Black, he was
Jayson’s journalistic godfather. Or rabbi. Or mentor. Or anything else
you want to call it. That’s not the Gerald Boyd I know. In 1976,
Gerald and I had lunch at the Original, a soul food restaurant in North
St. Louis. We had been discussing forming an organization of local
Black journalists, which became the Greater St. Louis Association of
Black Journalists, and decided we wanted to develop a workshop for
Black high school students interested in journalism. I drove
Gerald back to City Hall, which was his beat at the time, and sitting
in my car, we designed the entire workshop, deciding how it would focus
on in-class deadline writing, how we would simulate press conferences,
and how we would excite them about our profession. We decided that
Gerald would focus on building the organization, which he did as the
group’s first president. I became founding director of the St. Louis
Minority Journalism Workshop, a position I held (except for the year I
served as president of the chapter) from 1977 to 1983, when I left to
join the “Chicago Tribune.” During that period, more than 300
students came through our program. Many of our former students have
since become our colleagues. And more important, some of our former
students went on to establish and direct similar workshops in other
cities. I dare any commentator who suggests that Gerald is soft
on someone because they are Black to interview our former students and
ask them if he’s soft on African-Americans. Ask Ann Scales, a
former White House correspondent for the “Boston Globe.” Ask Marcia
Davis, a Style section editor at the “Washington Post.” Ask Mark
Russell, metropolitan editor of the “Cleveland Plain Dealer.” Ask Andre
Jackson, assistant managing editor for business editor of the “St.
Louis Post-Dispatch.” Ask Bennie Currie, a reporter for the Associated
Press in Chicago. Ask Bennie’s wife, Celeste Garrett, urban affairs
editor of the “Chicago Tribune.” Ask Alvin Reid, city editor of the
“St. Louis American.” Ask Russ Mitchell, an anchor and correspondent
for CBS News. Ask any of the other students. They know that, if
anything, he pushes them harder. We are the people who know Gerald Boyd. Many of those writing about him have no clue about who he is or what he represents.
Next Column:
FCC Decision to Expand Media Ownership will Curb Dissent
Back To Columns |