|
It was considered major
news four years ago when Lovie Smith’s Chicago Bears squared off against the
Indianapolis Colts, coached by Tony Dungy. It was the first time an African
American coach – in this case, two black coaches – had led an NFL team to the Super
Bowl.
Now another black coach,
Mike Tomlin of the Pittsburgh Steelers, leads a team that will face the Green
Bay Packers in the Super Bowl, the seventh time in the last 10 years that a
team with a black head coach or general manager has reached the game. Next
season, there will be eight minority coaches in the NFL, including seven
African Americans. Of the four teams competing in the NFC and AFC championship
games this season, two were coached by African Americans. That’s a long way
from 2002, when Dungy and Herman Edwards were the only black head coaches in
the NFL.
How did the NFL make such
dramatic progress?
Everybody points to the
“Rooney Rule,” named in honor of Steelers owner Dan Rooney, the chairman of the
NFL owners’ diversity committee. The rule requires teams to interview at least
one minority candidate for every head-coach vacancy. It was put into effect
after two lawyers, Cyrus Mehri and Johnnie L. Cochran Jr., authored a report in
2002 documenting that African American NFL coaches were held to a higher
standard than white coaches, even those with losing records.
The report found that the
five blacks who had coached during the modern era routinely outperformed white
coaches. In their first year, they averaged 2.7 more wins, even though they had
inherited less successful teams. And when they were fired, they had won an
average of 1.3 more games than white coaches who were dismissed.
Since 1920, the NFL has
hired more than 400 head coaches. Of those, only six (a little more than 1
percent) were African Americans, the report noted. Although nearly 70 percent
of the players in the NFL were black, only 6 percent of the head coaches and 28
percent of the offensive and defensive coordinators, often stepping-stone jobs
to becoming a head coach, were black.
After the report was
presented to NFL owners, with the implicit threat of litigation, they accepted
the recommendation that a person of color be considered for each head-coach
opening.
“Today, there are eight
minority coaches — three hired this season — both of which are records. We went
from zero black general managers to five. The guys who have gotten the
opportunities have been a smashing success,” Mehri said. “In the last five
Super Bowls, there were five black head coaches. There have been two black
general managers — Rod Graves of the Cardinals and Jerry Reese of the Giants.
None of this would have happened but for the Rooney Rule. … What more powerful
message can we send to this country than diversity is the key to success?”
The lessons of the NFL can
be applied in non-sports settings, according to N. Jeremi Duru, a Temple
University law professor and author of Advancing the Ball: Race, Reformation,
and the Quest for Equal Coaching Opportunity in the NFL.
“What we have seen is that
when you have that environment created by the diverse candidates slate,
oftentimes you’ve got candidates that wouldn’t have gotten a shot,” he said.
Duru cited Tomlin as an example.
“The Steelers have taken to
heart this idea that you look far and wide,” Duru explained. “You don’t just
look at what’s in front of you, where you see Ken Whisenhunt and Russ Grimm” – assistant Steelers coaches considered the
leading candidates to succeed Bill Cowher as head coach when he retired. Tomlin
was one of the people they took a look at.
The look paid off. Tomlin
took the Steelers to the playoffs in his first year, won the Super Bowl in his
second season, and is in his second Super Bowl in three seasons.
Duru said expanding the
pool of candidates to fill vacancies was a nonthreatening approach to
diversity.
“There’s no quota system in
it,” he explained. “It’s just that one person gets an interview. There’s no
hiring mandate. Indeed, among interviewees, there’s no requirement that there
be only four candidates, one of whom must be of color. You can interview as
many as you want. Therefore, there’s no individual that’s being excluded
because this person of color is being included. There’s nothing unfair about
it.”
Such an approach, he said,
fosters a fairer workplace.
“If you explore a situation
of one of those teams — take the Bears with Lovie Smith, or Mike Tomlin of the
Steelers — you can see that you have expanded opportunity and gotten better,”
Duru said. “If you can do that in corporate America and you get a CEO you
wouldn’t have thought about and suddenly your profits are up, productivity is
up, and inefficiency is down, I think pretty much anybody except a staunch
racist would realize the benefits that flow from broad-minded thinking.”
George Curry is a
former Washington correspondent and New York bureau chief for the Chicago
Tribune and was editor-in-chief of Emerge magazine. E-mail him at
gcurry@phillynews.com.
Next Column:
Recession has Expanded Racial Economic Gap
Back To Columns |