If you had difficulty observing more than an occasional African
American face among delegates attending the Republican National
Convention this week in St. Paul, there is a reason. According
to a roster of black delegates compiled by the Joint Center for
Political and Economic Studies, there are only 36 black delegates
attending this week's convention, a 78.4 percent decline from the 167
black delegates at the 2004 Republican convention. At 1.5 percent of
the delegation, this is the lowest black representation at a GOP
convention in 40 years. By contrast, the recently concluded
Democratic National Convention in Denver drew a record 1,079 African
American delegates, representing 24.3 percent of the total count. It's
easy to dismiss the different participation rates by noting that the
overwhelming majority of African Americans vote Democratic. That is
true. But to stop the analysis there ignores some important history
and, more important, today's political reality. For years, blacks
were solid Republicans. Even as late as 1960, when John F. Kennedy
barely defeated Richard M. Nixon, the GOP received 32 percent of the
black vote. But when Republicans selected ultra-conservative
Barry Goldwater as their presidential candidate in 1964, black support
for the party dropped to 6 percent and has never exceeded 15 percent
since that time. Not only did the party change, but so did the type of African Americans they pushed to the forefront. Former
Massachusetts Sen. Edward Brooke, former Assistant Secretary of Labor
Arthur Fletcher, and former Secretary of Transportation William Coleman
were Republicans, but they retained credibility in the black community
because they were firm supporters of affirmative action and other
social programs. Beginning with Ronald Reagan, it appeared that
any black Republican hoping to rise in the party was required to
denounce affirmative action, even in cases where they had personally
benefited from race-sensitive programs. I always find it amusing
that it's acceptable that every other interest group in the United
States is expected to look out after their own best interest. Yet, when
African Americans do the same thing, they are often called racists and
dismissed as being obsessed with color. Case in point: When I
have referred to the NAACP Legislative Report Card in this column,
invariably I have received at least one e-mail, usually more, saying
elected officials shouldn't cave in to the NAACP. Yet, the same
judgment is not rendered against other groups that seek to look after
their interests. Hundreds of organizations issue annual report cards
showing how members of Congress did or did not support their favorite
legislation. Among them: the National Education Association,
the Heritage Foundation, the ACLU, Citizens for Tax Justice, the
American Geriatrics Society, Americans for Better Immigration, and
Americans for the Arts Action Fund. It is a given that the
respective groups know what's in their best interest. Often, however,
African Americans are held to a different standard. The NAACP has
been issuing a civil rights report card since 1914. When it comes out,
there are often efforts to discredit it, as though the NAACP doesn't
know what's good for black people. If you read the last report
card for the complete session of Congress (the 109th), you might learn
why Republicans have such a difficult time attracting African Americans. In
the 109th Congress, 25 Democrats in the Senate received an A from the
nation's oldest civil rights organization, 15 earned a B, and two got
C's. None was graded D or F. By contrast, no Republican senator
earned an A or B. One, Lincoln Chafee of Rhode Island, earned a C, and
another, Mike DeWine of Ohio, was given a D. The other 54 Republicans
who served the full session earned F's. There was a similar
pattern in the House, where 133 Democrats earned A's, 41 got B's, 15
received C's, and 19 brought up the rear with D's. Among Republicans,
none earned as high as a C. Three received the highest grade of D and
211 got F's. (The totals in both chambers do not add up to 535 because some members served only partial terms and others were independents.) As
I pointed out in an earlier column, over 11 grading periods, John
McCain received an F each time; he got an Incomplete the two times he
ran for president and was often absent from the Senate. His
highest score was 50 percent (1985-86), his second-highest was 40
percent (1997-98). The other nine times, he supported the NAACP 30
percent of the time or less. More significant, McCain's support
of the NAACP has grown worse in recent years. Though he now apologizes
for voting against making the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s
birthday a national holiday, he has expressed support for a Ward
Connerly-backed initiative that would ban affirmative action in Arizona. African
Americans would like nothing better than to have a genuine choice
between Democrats and Republicans. However, despite kinder and gentler
words, the GOP's modern record on civil rights does not match the
rhetoric.
Next Column:
Senator Ted Kennedy's Profile in Courage
Back To Columns |