Within the past two months, I have given the keynote speech at a
health disparities conference in Chattanooga, Tenn. sponsored by the
Tennessee Department of Health, moderated a panel in D.C. on the same
subject for the National Medical Association and moderated a panel at
yet another conference in Virginia organized by Hampton University’s
Health Disparities Reduction Project. At each event, the same
point was made: Of the 15 leading causes of death in the United States,
Blacks had higher death rates than Whites in 11 areas: heart disease,
cancer, stroke, accidents, diabetes, flu and pneumonia, kidney
diseases, septicemia, homicide, cirrhosis of the liver and
hypertension. African-Americans had lower death rates than Whites as a
result of respiratory diseases, Alzheimer’s, suicide and aortic
aneurysm. Professor David R. Williams, a senior research
scientist at the University of Michigan’s Institute for Social
Research, has done significant research in this area. He presented many
of his findings to the audience at Hampton and has written about them
in the National Urban League’s “State of Back America 2004.” One
of the most stunning points made by Williams was that although overall
health has improved in the U.S. over the past 50 years, racial
differences in health are unchanged or widened. “The age-adjusted
overall death rate for African-Americans was 20 percent higher than
that of Whites in 1950 but 30 percent higher in 2000,” Williams says.
“Similarly, a Black baby born in the U.S.A. was 1.6 times as likely to
die before his/her birthday than a White infant in 1950, but is 2.5
times as likely in 2000.” To show the significance of the gap, in
1985 the Department of Health and Human Services began using the term
“excess deaths,” defined as the number of African-Americans who would
not die each year if Blacks and Whites had the same mortality rates.
According to the National Center for Health Statistics, there were
66,900 excess Black deaths in 1940; 50,900 in 1960; 80,600 in 1980 and
96,800 in 1998. From 1940 to 1998, according to the center, 4.27
million African-Americans died prematurely. Whites in the U.S. are hardly a model. Williams
says that when the infant mortality and life expectancy figures are
calculated for Whites alone, Caucasians fared poorly when measured
against other industrialized nations. If Whites made up their own
country, they would rank 24th in infant mortality deaths. At 5.8 deaths
per 1,000 births, Whites would trail top-ranked Hong Kong (3.1), Japan
(3.4), Sweden (3.4), Singapore (3.5), Finland (3.7) and seven other
countries (Norway, Denmark, France, Austria, Ireland, New Zealand and
Portugal). When looking at international life expectancy rates,
White women, averaging 80 years, would rank 19th and White men (74.5
years) would rank 20th. Men in Hong Kong live an average of 77.4 years,
longer than males anywhere else. They are followed by Japan (77.2),
Sweden (76) and Switzerland (76.3). Women live longest in Japan (84
years), followed by Hong Kong (83 years). As a country, Blacks
would rank 36th in infant mortality deaths (14.6 per 1,000 births). In
life expectancy, Black men would rank 34th if measured against other
men in the world (67.6 years). Black women would rank 35th among
feamles (74.8 years). “The subjective experience of
discrimination is a neglected but important source of stress,” Williams
points out. “Research indicates that acute and chronic experiences of
discrimination are stressful incidents that are adversely related to
physical and mental health.” He adds, “A small but growing body
of research indicates the health of African-Americans is adversely
affected when they buy into the larger society’s negative
characterization of Blacks.” Even with the clear health disparities, Williams argues that race is less of a health factor than education and economic status. “The
differences in life expectancy by education, within each race and
gender group (with the exception of White women) are larger than the
racial differences,” he states. However, that does not mean race can be ignored. “The
most disadvantaged White group (women who have not completed high
school) has a lower infant mortality rate than the most advantaged
Black group (college graduates),” he observes. Because income,
education and even where one lives help determine a person’s life
expectancy, Williams argues that in order to eliminate these
disparities, efforts should made to end housing discrimination, racism
and unequal access to health care. He observes, “Investments to
improve the social conditions and the health of African-Americans can
improve the health of the entire U.S. population and have long-term
positive consequences for non-Blacks as well.”
Next Column:
Sen. Hatch Uses Cartoon as a Smokescreeen
Back To Columns |