New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin has made some bold statements about race
in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. Whenever subsequently pressed
about such statements, however, Nagin keeps wimping out. It is time for
him to either shut up or stop backing down when challenged. Nagin’s
latest saga involves a speech he gave to the National Newspaper
Publishers Association (NNPA). At the event earlier this month in
Washington, D.C., Nagin made some clear references to race. The
Washington Post ran a story about his comments under the headline,
“Nagin Suspects a Plot to Keep Blacks Away.” When the New Orleans
Times-Picayune cited the Post’s account of his remarks, Nagin wimped
out. “I did not say anything racial," he told New Orleans
reporters. "… My take on it is that it was some young reporter in the
back of the room, looking for some way to get a nice story out. He
jumbled everything I said up, and brought some things in the middle of
the talk to the front, and painted this picture that was just not what
I intended to do, nor would I say." Rather than trying to
discredit Hamil Harris, the not-so-young Black Washington Post reporter
covering the event, Nagin should have told the truth. And the truth is
that he was accurately quoted. I know because I was in the room. And so
were members of International Business Kids, some future entrepreneurs
who videotaped his speech. Let’s review what he said. “It
wasn’t until I described my city, y’all know the story, until everybody
in America started to wake up and say way wait a minute, what is he
doing? What is he saying? Maybe we should try and do something
different to make sure that this man does not go any further. Because
they realized that I wasn’t a person to be controlled. I was going to
speak my mind especially when I saw our people suffer.” When
Nagin referred to his description of New Orleans and said, “Y’all know
the story,” there was no doubt that he was referring to his getting in
hot water for saying that God wants New Orleans to remain a “Chocolate
City.” Under pressure, he ate those words faster than he could chew a
slice of chocolate cake. For the record, many Blacks in New
Orleans thought that Nagin was controlled by corporate interests during
his first term and felt that he had done little for African-Americans
after receiving 80 percent of the White vote. In fact, Bishop Paul
Morton once described him as “a White man in Black skin.” After
losing his White base, Nagin was forced to court Black voters. In an
appearance before the National Conference of Black Mayors in Memphis,
for example, he referred to “people who don’t look like us.” Rather
than returning City Hall to a White mayor, Black voters in New Orleans
held their nose and voted for Nagin. In his speech to the NNPA,
Nagin said: “…the prognosticators were saying there’s no way you are
going to win because see they had dispersed all our people across 44
different states with one-way tickets out. They thought they were
talking about a different kind of New Orleans. They didn’t realize that
folk were awake and they were paying attention and they weren’t going
to let a plan unfold that changed all the history of what we have
fought for over many, many years.” Does Nagin really think an
audience that was at least 95 percent Black didn’t know he was
referring to African-Americans when he said “our people?” And in case there was any doubt, after Nagin complimented Rep. Maxine Waters, he said: “And
Maxine started to talk around the country. I remember when we went to
Memphis. She talked to Black folks around the country and tried to wake
them up and say look at what’s happening.” Here’s the statement that drew so much criticism back in New Orleans: “…
Because ladies and gentlemen what happened in New Orleans could happen
anywhere. They are studying this model, this model of a natural
disaster dispersing a community and changing the electoral process in
that community. We need to really understand what’s going on. When I
stood up and spoke out and they started to vilify, I knew there was
going to be a reaction. It’s a law of physics. For every action there’s
a reaction. I knew it was going to happen, but I didn’t realize how
strong it was going to happen...” And apparently Nagin doesn’t
realize that he can’t run from his words. If he believes what he says,
then he should have the courage to stand behind his words and stop
blaming the messenger for accurately reporting his message.
Next Column:
Life has Deteriorated in Iraq Since U.S. Invasion
Back To Columns |