The cover of Time magazine says it all, “Back to Segregation: After
four decades of struggle, America has now given up on integration.
Why?” The article states, “In fact, the high court’s action has
accelerated the pace at which cities across the country are moving to
undo mandatory desegregation. And the federal judiciary, which long
staked its authority on the enforcement of desegregation orders,
appears eager to depart the field.” Chris Hansen of the American
Civil Liberties Union in New York City is quoted: “The courts are
saying, ‘We still agree with the goal of school desegregation, but it’s
too hard, and we’re tired of it, and we give up.” The article
observes, “The combination of legal revisionism and residential
segregation is effectively ending America’s bold attempt to integrate
the public schools.” Kevin Brown, a law professor at the
University of Indiana and an expert on race and education, stated: “We
have already seen the maximum amount of racial mixing in public schools
that will exist in our lifetime.” Were these fresh reactions to
last week’s Supreme Court setback severely restricting the use of race
in the assignment of students to public schools in Seattle and
Louisville? No. The above quotes were taken from the April 29, 1996
issue of Time magazine –more than 11 years ago. In essence,
desegregation of public elementary and high schools was abandoned long
before the Roberts court ruling put yet another nail in the coffin of
integration. The cruel irony is that at a time when the U.S. is
rapidly becoming more racially and ethnically diverse – in less than 50
years, Whites will become a minority in this country -- the judicial
system is mandating a more segregated society. Conservatives will
no doubt hail desegregation has another failed American experiment.
That’s far from the truth. Like the War on Poverty, it has been a
half-hearted experiment lacking courageous or consistent national
leadership. Although few people are willing to admit it,
desegregation was never truly a national experiment. Most of the
efforts to tear down the walls of segregation were aimed at the South
while the rest of the nation, practicing more subtle forms of racism,
looked on. Because of the 1954 and 1955 Brown v. Board of
Education decisions, the South shifted from being the most segregated
region in the nation to the most desegregated. The Harvard Civil Rights
Project, using figures compiled by the Southern Education Reporting
Service, had published a chart to captures the dramatic changes. In
1954, 0.001 percent of Blacks attended majority White schools in the
South. In 1960, the figure was only 0.1 percent. In 1964, a decade
after the original Brown ruling, the figure stood at 2.3 percent. There
was a tremendous spurt from 1968 to 1988 when the percentage of
African-Americans attending majority White schools in the South jumped
from 23.4 percent to 43.5 percent. After peaking in 1988, things
started going downhill. “One of the most consistent trends of the
last decade is a reversal of gains in desegregation for black students
made in the South in the late 1960s and 1970s as a result of judicial
and executive enforcement of desegregation orders,” says a Harvard
report. “In fact, court-ordered desegregation of black students in
Southern states resulted in the South becoming the most integrated
region in the country, with 43.5 percent of black students in majority
white schools in 1988. “In the 1990s, as the desegregation
plans have been dismantled across the South, however, the proportion of
black students in majority white schools has decreased by 13 percentage
points. In 2000, black segregation rates in the South continue to
increase steadily as they have for over a decade. Today, only 31
percent of Southern black students are in majority white schools, a
rate lower than any year since 1968.” A study by the Harvard
Civil Rights Project titled “Racial Transformation and the Changing
Nature of Segregation” observes, “For the first nineteen years
following Brown, the Supreme Court simply ignored segregation outside
the seventeen Southern and Border states and Washington, D.C., those
with a history of state-imposed segregation.” “Since 1980, the
Northeast remains the region with the highest share of blacks attending
predominantly minority schools, with almost four out of every five
blacks in these schools,” the Harvard report states. That Time
magazine article carried an interesting quote 11 years ago by Harvard
sociologist Gary Orfield: The whole discussion of desegregation is
corrupted by the fact that we mix up race and class. You don’t gain
anything from sitting next to somebody with a different skin color. But
you gain a lot from moving from an isolated poverty setting into a
middle-class setting.” The latest Supreme Court ruling makes it more difficult to travel that route.
Next Column:
George Bush’s Bigotry of High Expectations
Back To Columns |