About a decade ago, conservative commentator Armstrong Williams and
I were debating the issue of affirmative action at a branch of North
Carolina State University. “May I ask you a question?” Williams
uttered. “You just did,” I curtly replied. “Well, may I ask you another
one?” Williams continued. “You just did that, too,” I retorted. When
Williams became visibly agitated, I knew I had disrupted his train of
thought and would easily win the debate. No, I didn’t learn that
technique from the talking heads on TV. I learned that in my debate
classes at Knoxville College in the late 1960s. There are many settings
in which debating skills can be helpful, whether it is in thinking
clearly, developing refined arguments or effectively making a point. When
“The Great Debaters,” staring and directed by Denzel Washington and
produced by Oprah Winfrey, opens in theaters on Chrisman Day, I am
hoping it will have a revolutionary impact on young people and give
them a better appreciation for effective communication. Sometimes
I wonder what Mr. Austin, my debate teacher at Knoxville College, or
Mrs. Malinda Prude, one of my English teachers at Druid High School in
Tuscaloosa, Ala., would say about how our young people express
themselves today. I’m no prude yet I am astonished by the vulgarity and
plain incoherence I hear, whether listening to teens talk to one
another or hearing them chat – usually loudly -- on the cell phone.
Let’s face it, much of it is unintelligible. And what we can
decipher does not paint a pretty picture. I had just finished speaking
at a university when a young man approached me after my presentation.
After every other fragmented sentence, he added: “Know what I am
sayin’?” Finally, I told him no, I didn’t know what he was saying.
Further, if I knew what he was saying, there would be no need for him
to say it again. Many adults are also sloppy in their use of
language. I’ve heard adults refer to “reverting back” too many times to
count. How else can one revert? You can’t revert forward. Or, they will
ask you to “repeat that again.” Repeat, by definition, is again. Even
more prevalent are people saying they need to go to an ATM machine. ATM
stands for Automated Teller Machine. So, when one says he or she is
going to the “ATM machine,” they are, in effect, saying they are going
to the “automated teller machine machine.” Perhaps we’d hear less
of this nonsense if more people had studied the art of debate, which is
what inspired the movie. “The Great Debaters” is based on a 1935
national championship debate between Wiley, a historically Black
college in Texas, and the University of Southern California, the
defending national champion. In typical Hollywood fashion, Wiley’s
opponent is changed to Harvard instead of U.S.C. The debate
coach, Melvin B. Tolson, was born in Moberly, Mo. and graduated from
Lincoln University, a historically Black college in Pennsylvania. Wiley
hired him in 1924 to teach English and speech. He also coached the
junior varsity football team, headed the theater club and formed the
Wiley Forensic Society, the debating team. Over a 15-year-period, Wiley
College lost only one of 75 debates. Denzel Washington told
reporters that both hip-hop and a form of poetry known as the spoken
word have their roots in Black oral tradition. “Our oral history is
rich and deep, and debating is a big part of it,” Washington said. Tolson
left Wiley in 1947 to teach at another HBCU, Langston University in
Oklahoma. He later served two terms as mayor of Langston and Liberia
declared him its poet laureate. He died in 1966. Wiley, which has
an enrollment of less than 900, is located in Marshall, Texas, a town
of 24,000 people approximately 140 miles east of Dallas. It has
produced such distinguished alumni as James Farmer, the former head of
the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE), and Herman Sweat, who won a
landmark Supreme Court decision against the University of Texas’
Whites-only admission policy. In recent years, the college has
struggled with limited finances and resources. “The Great Debaters” is
expected to shine a spotlight on the college, perhaps enabling it to
increase fundraising and enrollment. The debate team, which was
dismantled upon Tolson’s departure, has been revived and students are
eager to join upon learning about what the school calls a David vs.
Goliath victory over a major White university with considerably more
means. Wiley President Haywood Strickland hopes the movie will
strike a blow for all HBCUs, whose worth is often devalued.
Representing only 3 percent of the nation’s colleges and universities,
HBCUs account for a quarter of all Black college graduates. “The
Davids of the world are the Wiley Colleges of the world,” President
Strickland said. “We do have a slingshot called the mind.”
Next Column:
Homicide Economics
Back To Columns |