Philip Dixon, the chairman of the Journalism Department at Howard
University and former managing editor of the Philadelphia Inquirer, and
I were having a conversation recently about Jack Kelley, the USA
Today’s White version of Jayson Blair. Do you think they pushed
him along too quickly because he was White? Was he a White male old boy
network hire? Did his White bosses put him on the fast track because he
was White? Did he have a White mentor? And would a Black reporter other
than Jayson Blair be kept on staff that long after making so many
errors? Does this reflect on all White reporters? Will they be looked
at differently now? Dixon and I laughed as we peppered each other
with these and similar questions, largely because they were a variation
of the ridiculous ones being asked earlier about Blair, the New York
Times’ serial liar. Dixon and I agreed that Kelley, who resigned under
pressure in January, was worse than Blair because of the steps he took
to cover up his plagiarism. And there was plenty to cover up. A
special team of USA Today reporters, aided by three well respected
outside editors, reviewed more than 700 of Kelley’s stories written
over the past decade. The paper reported on March 19: “… an extensive
examination of about 100 of the 720 stories uncovered evidence that
found Kelley’s journalistic sins were sweeping and substantial.” The
story that almost won a Pulitzer Prize three years ago was about a
suicide bombing at a Jerusalem pizza parlor. Kelley filed a story that
said, “Three men, who had been eating pizza inside, were catapulted out
of the chairs they had been sitting on. When they hit the ground, their
heads separated from their bodies and rolled down the street.” He
claimed the heads rolled “with their eyes still blinking.” Editors
deleted the “eyes still blinking” part of the story. They should have
pulled the entire article. By his own account, Kelley was 90 feet away
and was thrown to the ground, with his back to the pizzeria. Unless he
had eyes in the back of his head, Kelley could not have witnessed what
asserted that he had seen. Kelly also claimed that to have met
the bomber just minutes before the explosion. In an interview with CNN,
he said, “there was [the] gentleman’s head laying on the floor, and I
could recognize him as the gentleman who I had saw…” USA Today
reporters investigating Kelley’s work learned from Israel’s national
police that the bomber’s head and upper torso hit the ceiling and got
stuck in an oven vent during the explosion. Therefore, Kelley could not
have possibly seen it on the floor. His sins didn’t stop there. The
team of investigators found, “Kelley wrote scripts to help at least
three people mislead USA Today reporters trying to verify his work,
documents retrieved from his company-owned laptop computer show. Two of
the people are translators Kelley paid for services months or years
before. Another is a Jerusalem businessman, portrayed by Kelley as an
undercover Israeli agent.” Even Jayson Blair didn’t go that far. Speaking
of Blair, he continues to prove that he is a shameless liar. Not only
did his behavior prompt the resignation of Gerald M. Boyd, the New York
Times first Black managing editor, he even told a malicious lie about
Boyd’s mother. In his book, he wrote that Boyd’s mother “died
following a long struggle with drugs.” However, Boyd disclosed in his
syndicated column, “Odessa Thomas Boyd, my mother, was 29 years old
when she died, after a lifetime battle with sickle cell anemia.” He
continued, “My mother's life was one of making the best of an awful
situation, which she did with courage and without complaint. It is
unconscionable that a journalist would write something so hurtful. The
truth is that my mother did not drink or smoke, and she certainly never
used drugs.” Frankly, I don’t know why anyone would want to
read or listen to what Jayson Blair has to say about anything unless
they were interested in fiction. Even then, they could find better
selections. Yet, this admitted liar can get a book contract, be
interviewed on network TV newsmagazine shows and be welcomed at book
signings across the country. If USA Today really wants to
imitate The New York Times, the top two editors will resign. And
Kelley, taking a cue from Blair’s lead, will no doubt be offered a book
contract to write more lies.
Next Column:
Black Press is Indispensable
Back To Columns |